Before the students were off and writing for Writer's Workshop today, we did our weekly Philosophy lesson since the 8th graders were having a fantastic learning experience at Chabot Space and Science Center yesterday.
This week's lesson is entitled, "Is Beauty a Matter of Fact or a Matter of Taste?" and lively discussions ensued after learning the philosophical reasonings of Socrates and David Hume.
HOMEWORK: Wednesday, February 10: Write at least two full paragraphs, with supported evidence, answering one of the Discussion Questions below. Highlight every "to/too/two," "there/they're/their," and "your/you're" and edit them if required.
1. Review the dialogue at the beginning of this chapter. Would Duana agree more with Socrates or Hume? What about Zach? Give evidence.
2. Do you think statements about beauty are objective or subjective? Defend your answer.
3. Do you agree with Socrates that human beings are born with natural knowledge of beauty? Why or why not?
4. Do you agree with Hume's belief that all knowledge comes from experience? Why or why not?
5. Socrates is famous for having said "The unexamined life is not worth living." What do you think he meant in this statement?